Forcing a circle into a square: 12 common misconceptions about community engagement

Author
Hannah Mogul-Adlin, Senior Communications Manager
Date
March 16, 2022
National Consumer Scholars sit thoughtfully around a table as one participant talks and gestures with his hand.
October 7, 2022
Understanding preferred language for ‘people with lived experience’
We surveyed fifteen participants in our consumer leadership programs to learn what language they liked — and disliked — to describe their role.
Evelyne Kane, Senior Program Manager, Community Engagement & Capacity Building
Renee talks to care team members in the Camden Coalition office
September 27, 2022
RELATE: Helping supervisors support their frontline staff — and prevent burnout
Learn about our new stand-alone training, designed specifically for supervisors of frontline complex care team members.
Paula Derrow, Freelance Writer
Marisol writes in a notebook after talking on the phone with a patient
September 7, 2022
Building genuine patient relationships over the phone
The pandemic and a telephonic social needs navigation program showed how to build authentic healing relationships over the phone.
Marisol Caban, Associate Director of Care Management Initiatives
Author Avani Kashyap at the Camden waterfront
August 31, 2022
Good intentions aren’t enough: Escaping the mindset of poverty porn
A Camden Coalition summer intern reflects on the difference between idealism and solidarity.
Avani Kashyap, Student, Washington and Lee University
Camden Coalition staff members cheer with their hands raised at the end of a team huddle
August 23, 2022
Strengthening ecosystems of care is the future of the complex care field and the way to address social drivers of health
Care coordination on a person-by-person basis is only the first step — which is why ecosystems are at the center of our 2022-2025 strategic plan.
Kathleen Noonan, President and CEO
A patient holds her baby
July 27, 2022
Supporting pregnant and parenting people who use drugs: A new toolkit and webinar
Everyone deserves access to quality healthcare and social support without the fear of criminalization.
Emily Wasuna, Program Manager for Field Building and Resources; Kyli Rodriguez-Cayro, Content Manager, Overdose Prevention Program at Vital Strategies

According to Victor Murray, Senior Director of Community Engagement and Capacity Building, the goal of community engagement at the Camden Coalition is simply “to amplify the voice of the community in our work so that people are represented. The goal is that the concerns, needs, priorities, and aspirations of the Camden community are what drive our organizational and program decisions.” 

Victor Murray started working at the Camden Coalition 12 years ago as an intervention specialist. He helped shape our care management model and principles, and led our Care Management Initiatives department before working with our National Center team to teach our model of care to organizations across the country. In his current role, he focuses on partnering with communities locally and across the country, leading our community-level COVID response as well as our work partnering across sectors to improve system-level coordination and increase access to behavioral health, housing, and social services in Camden.

Victor was born and grew up in Camden, where, he notes, decades of government mismanagement and inequitable resource distribution have always been challenged by individuals willing to show up and advocate for their community. Throughout his years living and working in Camden, he’s heard a lot of misconceptions about the Camden community, as well as about the practice of community engagement.

Right now community engagement is ‘the thing to do,’ it’s very en vogue right now,” he says. “And not that that’s the worst thing in the world, but there’s not a lot of conversation about how it should be done effectively.”

In the spirit of sharing best practices for effective community engagement, here are 12 misconceptions that Victor has seen in the course of his work, and advice for how organizations (including the Camden Coalition) can become more community-driven.

Misconception #1: Community engagement only happens at the program or organizational level. “Community engagement is often talked about in the context of a single program or a single organization but not often in the context of an entire ecosystem or an entire region. So one shortcoming in terms of how people are talking about it is that it tends to be very, very narrow, and that’s how voices get missed.”

Misconception #2: Engaging the community starts with a blank slate. “Just because an organization is starting to do more formal community engagement doesn’t mean that this is the first time the community is interacting with the organization. Some of those past interactions — including poor service delivery and cutting participants off from programs — could have been bad and may have even caused trauma. Not addressing and reckoning with these past interactions is like a train showing up at terminal C, yelling ‘Everyone hop on! We have this great destination to get to!’ without talking about what happened at terminals A and B, where people were kicked off or not let on the train at all.”

Misconception #3: Community engagement has to be difficult. “I was at one of our vaccine events recently, thinking about how, yes, this is community engagement, but also it felt like I was just out in the neighborhood, you know? I think when it does become complex or difficult it’s because we’re trying to force a circle into a square, or force a conversation to fit a certain narrative or organizational vision or goal. So sometimes those misalignments become complex, but I don’t know that the work itself is as difficult as some would make it out to be.”

Misconception #4: Community feedback is a stamp of approval at the end of a process. “Often organizations can be hesitant about when to incorporate the community voice or perspective. It should be before we define a problem, before we set the agenda. Sometimes organizations want to set the table before inviting the community in. It should be, ‘come help us set the table, come help us figure out the menu.’ Sometimes we just want to invite folks in for the meal just to get their approval. Like, ‘It was great, right?’ By then it’s too late for meaningful conversation or feedback.”

Misconception #5: Community engagement is like public relations: community members should see the most polished versions of our organizations. “It’s always a challenge as organizations to let community members come in and experience the messiness inherent in planning programs or changing our processes. But the thing is — they’re already experiencing the messiness of our organizations from the outside, when they’re accessing or trying to navigate through our services. Being transparent about that messiness takes a level of vulnerability on the organization’s part that we don’t often talk about. Community engagement isn’t, ‘We’re doing so great, rah rah,’ it’s about having challenging conversations where we name and address the stuff that needs to change.”

Misconception #6: Community members should be treated as volunteers. “The feedback and partnership you’re getting from community members is valuable for your organization, so compensate them. Pay them. Show them that you value their time. Keep in mind though, that for community members on public benefits, too much income can affect their eligibility for benefits, so you may need to be creative.”

Misconception #7: Community engagement is a separate beast from patient/client engagement. “Ultimately, community engagement and partnership building in general is about the same things we emphasize in our patient/client-level work: being authentic, being consistent, setting clear boundaries. We tend to do much better at the patient/client level at understanding why people don’t do what we want, what their reservations might be, empathizing with challenges while still pushing for change. That’s a balance that needs to be found at the community level as well.”

Misconception #8: Our organization should be the protagonist in our community members’ stories.Promoting empathetic and empowering storytelling means that rather than centering our organization as the protagonist, how can we ensure the consumer themself is cast in the central role? When it comes to storysharing, how do we center consumers and honor their stories? A few ways: by not having them change their narrative to fit ours. By not forcing their story to align with our mission, initiatives, and outcomes. And by talking about people as whole people, not just a disease or set of challenges.”

Misconception #9: We can jump right into a community engagement project, then move on to the next thing once it’s done. “It’s hugely helpful to set clear expectations going into projects. What is the vision for this partnership? What is everyone’s capacity, what are people’s concerns, what are they most anxious about? It goes back to that vulnerability. A lot of times organizations aren’t willing to go there. And then, once the work is done it’s done. There’s no debrief where we say what we have learned, what we’re taking away from this work, how we want to build upon the work.” 

Misconception #10: Community engagement is the answer to our DEI issues. “There’s a lot of energy around advancing health equity and DEI [diversity, equity, and inclusion] right now, and community engagement is an important part of that conversation. However, community engagement should not be the only lever your organization is pulling to advance those goals. Organizations should also be thinking about internal work, including workforce engagement, development, and recruitment. How do the demographics of your staff and leadership mirror or not mirror the community that you serve?”

Misconception #11: We might do something wrong, so it’s better to do nothing. “Conversations about community engagement can be similar to DEI conversations. Sometimes organizations get paralyzed with the fear that they will do something wrong or do something to offend. We just need to get past that. That’s your own individual or organizational baggage. To really make change, we have to push ourselves in ways that are sometimes uncomfortable. Sometimes we will trip up, but what’s more important is the rebound. How did you use that as a moment to think differently moving forward?”

Misconception #12: We have it all figured out! “At the Camden Coalition, we’ve gotten a lot right, but the way we talk about community engagement is still very narrow. It’s a slice of a slice which doesn’t necessarily represent the Camden or South Jersey population as a whole. Something I’m always thinking about is, what does our community engagement ladder up to? As we build this ecosystem of care in Camden, what would this community engagement look like on a more broad level, outside of just this very specific sub-population of people with complex health and social needs? There’s still work to do on our end.”

Victor stresses that the most important element for effective community engagement is just to start. “I think a lot of people get stuck at ‘where do I start,’” he says. “It’s not rocket science — you have a conversation with someone.”

Stay Informed

Join our mailing list to get the latest updates sent right to your inbox from the Camden Coalition.

Sign Up